Thank you very much! You are too awesome!
Extreme TMA System 16,195 replies
Happs with TMA Trading Journal 25 replies
Forex Reality Tour #1 - Market Trend % 48 replies
MTF TMA 287 replies
SnakeForce - simple TMA with alert? 3 replies
DislikedThanks for your kind words. I'm not sure which indicator you are referring to. However, if you are talking about non-repainting version of tma slope, I can assure you it accurately shows the slope value of the mid TMA line as it was at the close of each bar. Regardless of what nanningbob (assuming that's the NB you are referring to) might think, the calculations are correct. Spend some time using the indicators in a simulator and you can see for yourself.Ignored
DislikedHi zznbrm, first of all, thank you for share with us your knowledge and great skills in coding in this thread.
what we want to know is: are your 10.2 TMA slope True 4.30 (which I think itīs a very piece or art) based on the TMA OR use LWMA?Ignored
QuoteDislikedThe problem with the NonPainting TMA slope is it is not based on the TMA but uses LWMA that approximates the TMA
DislikedYes, it is possible. Compiled using build 432 of MT4.
Currency Slope Strength true.ex4 (14.5 KB, 23 views)Ignored
DislikedThere are a few reasons why the source code for the TMA Slope True indicators is not being made public (actually, the true calculations were previously shared...I'm sure they are out there somewhere)Ignored
Disliked1) There are so many versions of TMA Slope floating around. Many of these versions are coded very poorly and are simply inaccurate. And I don't like answering lots of questions about others mistakes.Ignored
Disliked2) Contrary to popular belief, it is not a magic indicator. The angles of the lines do not give some secret signal of trends and pending reversals.Ignored
Disliked3) You guys are so friggin desperate for the perfect indicator sent from the heavens. This ain't it. Some of us live in reality...not the dream world of English teachers and Spanish golfers.Ignored
Disliked4) I'm trying to get you guys to think a little bit. Figure out the true calculations for yourself.Ignored
DislikedPractice some actual analysis instead of this copy/paste style of programming.Ignored
DislikedIts been mentioned a few times that all the good coders have left FF and now practice coding with the piano teacher. That's great...put your minds together, study the indicators, learn the math behind them, and figure out how to calculate the values you want.Ignored
DislikedSometimes you have to work for it...the answers can't always be handed...Ignored
DislikedAlso, I'm sick of hearing that you can't do it because you don't know how to code. That's nothing but the convenient excuse of the lazy. Stop trading for a week and study mql4 (or the programming language for your platform). That is certainly enough time for even the most technically challenged to get a solid understanding so you won't need to depend on others all the time. If you are serious about this business, I'm sure it will be well worth your time.Ignored
DislikedThis answer is not meant to be rude or to insult you. I know you did many good programming work here. And I'm grateful for your work here.
What I don't understand is your argumentation and your attitude against people who are not as knowledgeable as you. Everybody started small at some point.Ignored
DislikedWell...it is obvious we have a different way of looking at things. I guess I'm the type of guy who would rather take a little extra time to try to figure out the solution to a problem myself. Not only does this provide one with a sense of accomplishment, but also the extra effort allows for a more thorough understanding of the process. I think some of the best developers on this forum share this philosophy: hayseed, Xaphod, CockeyedCowboy.Ignored
DislikedI can think of one time I asked someone to share their code for an indicator. They declined. It was no big deal really...I just spent the time to figure it out on my own. It worked out great because I learned a lot more doing it myself and even improved the indicator a little bit.Ignored
DislikedEventually someone will take the challenge and figure it out. Or someone will take the easy way out and simply decompile the code. Either way, I'm sure you will get your algorithm.Ignored
DislikedBesides, withholding source code is always a good way to get a rise out of a few individuals.Ignored
Dislikedfantastic new indicator, was just thinking aloud about this possibility over at the "other place" a couple of days ago, and there we have it - thanks a lot...
Would it be possible (as I can not look at the code...grin) to do a multi tf version (say three) instead of attaching indy three times?
Absolutely fantastic!Ignored
Disliked1. ohhh.... well whoever CB is, I like his thinking - and appreciate YOUR coding talent!Ignored
QuoteDisliked2. My request would be to allow max three tf inputs in the indicator (eg H1,H4, D1), attach it once and the respective columns are calculated and drawn at once - instead of attaching one indicator for each tf required
QuoteDisliked3. I know you normally don't do it, but I am really curious about the math of this, would you be willing to share the code or explain the math on finding the price where tma slope changes from ranging to buy or sell please
QuoteDislikedSome of the time I do post the source code for the items I share publicly. There are times when I don't and I have my reasons.
DislikedIn the screenshot below, green is buy (above 0.3 slope), red is sell (below -0.3 slope), and white is range...allowing the user to see the exact prices where the TmaSlope will change status. Mouseover the lines for the exact prices.
Hope it works for you!Ignored